Instructor notes: HR Diagram Inference Lab

Public notes (v0.2 policy). Not linked from primary navigation.

Exhibit: /cosmic-playground/exhibits/stars-zams-hr/

Overview

What this demo is for, how long it takes, and what misconception it targets.

  • Temperature alone determines total stellar luminosity.
  • Main-sequence fits apply equally to giant and compact remnant stars.
  • Metallicity only changes spectral lines and not bulk stellar structure.
  • Logarithmic axes distort physics rather than reveal dynamic range.

Activities

Suggested flow (edit as needed):

  1. Students write a prediction before touching controls.
  2. Students run the play steps in pairs and record evidence.
  3. Whole-class debrief: claim + evidence, then model limitations.

Assessment

  • 1–2 sentence explanation aligned to the “Explain” prompt.
  • One claim + one piece of evidence from the demo.

Model notes (deeper)

  • Main-sequence luminosity and radius use Tout et al. (1996) analytic ZAMS fits over 0.1 <= M/Msun <= 100 and 1e-4 <= Z <= 0.03.
  • Theorist HR mode uses base-10 logarithmic axes: log(L/L_sun) versus log(T_eff) with hot-left orientation.
  • Observer CMD mode uses M_V versus (B-V), with deterministic photometric scatter and brighter-up magnitude inversion.
  • Radius guides follow Stefan-Boltzmann scaling: $$\frac{L}{L_{\odot}}=\left(\frac{R}{R_{\odot}}\right)^2\left(\frac{T_{\rm eff}}{T_{\odot}}\right)^4$$.

Backlog

  • Add a proper instructor content collection for richer notes.
  • Improve station card parameter table to be demo-driven.
  • Add export-results scaffolding once runtime lands.