Tools of the Trade
Useful constants: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; .
Show explicit units, and for each result run a sanity check. Worked solutions are released after the homework due date.
Conceptual
Problem
⭐⭐ Dimensional analysis check. For each equation, decide whether it is dimensionally valid; if not, identify what is wrong.
- (a) Orbital velocity .
- (b) Kinetic energy .
- (c) Gravitational potential energy .
- (d) Pressure ( = density).
Reach for dimensional analysis: write each side in , , and demand they match. Use , energy , and pressure .
Two of these are wrong by a single power of a quantity. For (b), compare against ; for (c), check whether or gives energy.
Problem
⭐⭐ Stefan-Boltzmann scaling. .
- (a) Star A has twice the radius and twice the temperature of Star B; find .
- (b) A red giant has the Sun’s radius but its temperature; luminosity in ?
- (c) A white dwarf has the Sun’s radius and its temperature; luminosity in ?
Work with ratios — the constant cancels. Build each answer as .
For (a), the radius contributes and the temperature contributes ; multiply them. For (b), keep the powers organized: .
Problem
⭐ Building physical intuition. Without calculating, predict which way each quantity changes and by roughly what factor:
- (a) orbital period if you double orbital radius (same central mass);
- (b) escape velocity if you double a planet’s mass (same radius);
- (c) luminosity if you double a star’s temperature (same radius);
- (d) dynamical timescale if you double a cloud’s density.
Each part hinges on one scaling law: , , , and . Read the exponent off the relevant relation.
Doubling the input multiplies the output by . A negative exponent (as in the timescale) means the quantity decreases.
Calculation
Problem
⭐⭐ The dimensions of . Starting from :
- (a) derive the dimensions of in ;
- (b) verify the CGS unit () matches;
- (c) convert to CGS.
Solve for , then substitute the dimensions of force (), mass, and length. The masses and lengths rearrange to leave in pure .
For (c), and . Apply and as powers of ten, then collect the exponent.
Problem
⭐⭐ The dimensions of . For :
- (a) derive the dimensions of in ;
- (b) verify the CGS unit ();
- (c) convert to CGS.
Solve for : the is dimensionless, so . Luminosity is a power, .
For (c), and . Multiply the two conversion factors into the SI value and collect the power of ten.
Problem
⭐⭐ Kepler scaling. Using (years, AU):
- (a) Neptune orbits at 30 AU — estimate its period;
- (b) an asteroid has yr — estimate its semi-major axis;
- (c) a Kuiper Belt object at 40 AU — what period?
- (d) Sanity check: Pluto orbits at ~40 AU with period ~248 yr — does your answer agree?
In Solar-System units the constant is 1, so with in years and in AU. Going from to means ; going the other way, .
For (a), . For (b), , and is exact. Use (c) directly to check (d).
Problem
⭐⭐ Fermi estimation: light-minutes. Estimate without a calculator:
- (a) how far light travels in 1 s? in 1 min?
- (b) the Earth–Sun distance is cm — how many light-minutes is this?
- (c) Jupiter is ~5 AU from the Sun — how many light-minutes?
Light travels cm in 1 s. One light-minute is just — multiply, keeping only one significant figure since this is a Fermi estimate.
For (b), divide cm by your light-minute distance. For (c), you do not need a fresh calculation — Jupiter’s distance is Earth’s, so its light travel time is longer.
Synthesis
Problem
⭐⭐ Inverse-square law applications.
- (a) The Sun is 1 AU from Earth — how much fainter would it appear from Saturn (10 AU away)?
- (b) Two identical stars have apparent brightnesses in ratio 1 — ratio of their distances?
- (c) A supernova is visible to the naked eye from 10 kpc — how far could it be observed with a telescope collecting more light?
- (d) Limiting case: as distance , what happens to observed flux? What does this imply about detecting objects at arbitrarily large distances?
The tool is the inverse-square law: flux . For brightness ratios, ; for distances, invert it as .
For (a), the factor is . For (c), the detectable distance grows as the square root of the collected-light factor, so — apply that to 10 kpc.
Problem
⭐⭐ Complete workflow: escape velocity. .
- (a) Dimensional check: verify this has dimensions of velocity.
- (b) Ratio method: Earth’s escape velocity is 11.2 km/s — using ratios, estimate the Moon’s (, ).
- (c) Unit conversion: convert Earth’s escape velocity to cm/s.
- (d) OOM check: the Sun’s escape velocity is ~618 km/s — does this make sense given and ?
For (b), the constants and the factor of 2 cancel in a ratio: . Plug in and .
For (c), , so multiply km/s by . For (d), form the same ratio with and and compare against your factor.
Problem
⭐⭐ (Challenge) White dwarf mass-radius relation. Derive why more massive white dwarfs are smaller using dimensional analysis and pressure balance: degeneracy pressure scaling, the – relation, and gravitational pressure. Show the final scaling () and interpret the physics.
Set two pressures equal. Non-relativistic electron degeneracy pressure scales as , and number density . Gravitational pressure scales as .
Substitute into to get . Set and solve for in terms of — the powers of and rearrange to the stated scaling.